I'm now living within walking distance of this place, so am pretty biased, but. It's well worth a stop for day-tripping foodies.
Notable:
Bakery goodies. Apart from some good breads, there're sticky buns, cookies (chewy and large), butter tarts, etc, etc; all highly recommended.
A little deli. The cheese, from a little Ontario producer whose name escapes me right now, is excellent. The deli-salad-standards are surprisingly good.
Eggs. Oddly enough. See separate entry. Get the eggs.
Plus local goodies; jarred what-nots, and some frozen entrées from thevillagekitchen.ca/ -- have tried veg lasagna; good, very rich and creamy. My 2nd-last visit found ramps, aka wild leeks, for sale.
Eggs here are from the Bekings Poultry Farm
(Oxford Station, Ont)-- "All hens roam free. Wholesome all natural eggs from healthy grain fed chickens. Eggs the way they're supposed to taste."
Much better than a city supermarket egg, but without the hassle of tracking down a faded "Eggs for sale" sign at the end of a dusty gravel road. They're so stunningly fresh and tasty that poaching them is an entirely different thing from poaching the more easily found sort of egg. I am no egg expert, but these really do stand out.
I tried the famous sticky (cinnamon) buns from here and they were really quite good. The sticky part is almost toffee-like in consistency. I also picked up some butter tarts: pecan butter tarts and maple butter tarts. Both were of excellent quality, but the maple ones stood out for me. I'll make a point of picking some up whenever I pass through Pakenham!
Da Butcher