Hosted by WebFaction
Rating [2] · 11 thumbs up · 9 thumbs down
See also: The Wellington Diner


Photos
 
Foods from Elgin Street Diner
Reviews
Sign in to add a comment
RestaurantThing review
Showing comments 1 to 10
2011 Oct 8
Today for breakfast, the Elgin Street Diner had on special their "OMG Eggs Benedict," which is a bacon cheddar grilled cheese sandwich with a couple of poached eggs on top, covered with hollandaise of course. It was delicious in that "well, I don't have to have that again for another year or two" sort of way.

You can have the sandwich done with whole wheat, white or egg bread. I chose the egg bread, but next time I will choose the whole wheat, as a bit more texture to the bread would have been nice.
 
2010 Oct 9
Went there for breakfast a few times.
I always order the Dagwood club sandwich.
Very high and soooo delicious. Make sure
you're hungry or better...you can actually
share it. There's enough for two unless
you're a baseball player. Service can
sometimes be a bit slow but not bad for
a super busy place. Try the Dagwood...
Yummy for my tummy!!! :)
 
2010 Jul 23

1
Went for breakfast here once. I found the restaurant dirty. The service was slow and not very friendly. My eggs were overcooked and I don't know who thought frying mashed potatoes in a clump on a griddle would be appetizing? It was a mush that was sort of greyish in colour and still sort of cold in the middle. Wow, ESD wins my all time worst breakfast ever award! Mark me questionable if you must... somethings just have to be said.
 
2010 Jul 22

2
I've been there while under the influence and didn't really enjoy it either. I had the smoked meat - however I'm from Montreal and spoiled on late night dining :)

The one visit was my only one so I cannot comment on the food at other times of the day.
 
2010 Jul 20
Sorry, why is Dita's comment flagged but not Snoopy Loopy's????
 
2010 Jul 20

1
Drunk people are the only reason why this place is still running.

Have you ever been here at 3am on a weekend?
 
2009 Aug 6
Was at ESD this weekend and the server told me that the huevos rancheros might be added to the regular menu (right now it is only part of the "brunch specials" menu)!

I hope it gets added because it is yummy! And vegetarian!
 
2009 Jul 21

1
People actually eat here outside of the the hours of 2 am to 6 am? Strange =)
 
2009 Jul 21
When the poutine is good (fresh, crispy fries), it's really good. When the fries are a bit wilted, not so much. I love how salty it is.

Great milkshakes.

Good breakfasts- the bake beans are vegetarian and yummy. If you don't order the breakfast special, coffee is NOT included and is overpriced. Can lead to an expensive brekkie.

The salmon burger is okay, the veggie burger is homemade and slighty curried. Pretty good, a bit dense for my liking though.

The desserts are hit and miss- I had the banana cream cake recently and it was so so.

The service is super, the staff are so nice. The booths are comfy. The specials are interesting- I would try them more often if they had more veggie specials.
 
2009 Apr 1
My co-worker and I went to ESD for breakfast. I was pleasantly surprised. The bacon was crispy, the eggs cooked perfectly and the homemade beans were very good. They had a kick to them, cayenne maybe.. and they were not mushy. Our server was nice and had a good sense of humour. More expensive then Dunns, but much better and not as noisy. For me, the only thing I did not like were the potatoes, it was mashed potatoes and then lightly fried... too heavy and not enough crisp.
 

Older Sign in to add a comment
Showing comments 1 to 1
2007 Mar 27

1
The banana chocolate milkshake at the diner is quite possibly the best diner shake out there. Pass on the poutine, go for the milkshakes.
 


Poutine [2]
Sign in to add a comment
Showing comments 1 to 10
2011 Nov 10

2
One of the grossest poutine's around. a disgrace to poutine...but when it's the only thing open at 4 a.m..what else can you do? lol
 
2010 Jul 20

1
The only time I eat it is when drunk.
I do like the fact it is vegetarian.
It is very salty and the fries are way too thin for my liking.
 
2008 Mar 13
Love it because it is VEGETARIAN! That's right, apparently it's a mushroom based gravy!
 
2007 Oct 6
The poutine here is way too salty and I find it has an aftertaste. The fries are often limp and get soggy too fast.
 
2007 Jul 19
I'm a hardcore poutine nut, and every time I go to ESD (at the request of my not-so-French spouse), I order the poutine; not because I enjoy it, but because I forgot how lame it was the last time.

Their fries are just too small and shriveled to adequately serve as a vessel for the gravy and cheese. If only they'd cut them twice bigger, it would be pretty darn decent.
 
2006 Oct 24
I had an underwhelming smoked meat poutine last Friday. The meat was not the problem (fairly average yet tasty), but the poutine itself just wasn't up to snuff. The skinny fries were off-putting, and it didn't feel like there were enough cheese curds. Still, where else is an inebriated person going to get poutine after midnight?
 
2006 Sep 27
I like it thin and salty - you can better eat it with a knife and fork. The gimmicky experimentation also kind of charms me. But really it's just the fact that they celebrate poutine and give it special billing on the menu that urges me to celebrate alongside. I think my fave for the actual food is the light blue fry truck that parks(ed) along Slater near Kent and Bank Streets.
 
2006 Sep 27
Count me in that camp too. I found it way too salty (and I like salt) and with the skinny little fries it's nothing like real p'tin. But... it's still better than no poutine!!
 
2006 Sep 27
I am in the camp of people that don't get the "love Elgin Street Diner Poutine" mentality. Give me Sasha's or give me death!
 
2006 Sep 25
mmmmm. OKAY so I waited for almost 45 minutes for a poutine at 2:30 in the morning, BUT, IT WAS WORTH IT! It was amazing.
 

Older
Sign in to add a comment
Showing comments 1 to 1
2012 Feb 16

1
This sandwich is delicious as far as vegetarian diner fare goes, but when compared to anywhere that specializes in veggie-based meals, I give it a big fat meh. I'd reccomend using a red pepper spread instead of mayo to add flavour, and knock down the price! C'mon, I know what vegetables and bread cost.

 


Sign in to add a comment
Showing comments 1 to 1
2007 Sep 30
Sorry - I just can't get down with the fried mashed potatoes instead of homefries. I've tried to like this place, but there's much better value and food out there as far as breakfasts are concerned. The 24-hour breakfast special used to be ~$4 and it's probably twice that these days.

This restaurants thrives on it's reputation and location (OK the poutine is good, I'll give them that)